Case DescriptionCase Type: Gender Discrimination/Title IX
Organization: Dartmouth College
On January 29, 2020, the United States District Court for the District of New Hampshire granted preliminary approval of the class action settlement arising from the misconduct of former tenured professors Todd Heatherton, William Kelley, and Paul in Dartmouth’s Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences. Under the Settlement Agreement, Dartmouth has agreed to pay $14,000,000. In addition to this monetary payment, Dartmouth has agreed to a forward-looking commitment to undertake certain programmatic measures.
As directed by the Court, a notice was issued to class members on February 12, 2020. All Confidential Claim Forms and Required Certification Forms for eligibility to receive a supplemental payment are due by April 12, 2020.
To get more information about the settlement or submit your Confidential
Claim Form online,
Sanford Heisler Sharp filed a landmark Title IX class action lawsuit against Dartmouth College in New Hampshire federal court on behalf of female students in Dartmouth’s Department of Psychology and Brain Sciences (“PBS”). The Complaint alleges that Dartmouth willfully ignored more than a decade of widespread sexual harassment by tenured professors Todd Heatherton, William Kelley, and Paul Whalen, who formed a private “predators club” and treated the PBS Department like a “21st Century Animal House.”
Each of the seven named Plaintiffs is a highly accomplished female scientist. Kristina Rapuano, Andrea Courtney and Annemarie Brown all completed their doctorates in brain science at Dartmouth and are now at Yale, Stanford and Dartmouth, respectively. Vassiki Chauhan, Sasha Brietzke, and Jane Doe are currently or were formerly enrolled in Dartmouth’s PBS doctoral program. Marissa Evans is a graduate of Dartmouth College who focused her undergraduate studies on brain science in PBS.
Sexual Assault, Sexual Harassment, and Rape
The Complaint details how the three professors sexually assaulted, sexually harassed, and raped female students in the PBS Department. The Complaint chronicles how professors Heatherton, Kelley, and Whalen hired female lab assistants based on their physical attractiveness and were in competition to have the “hottest lab.”
Plaintiffs allege that these three professors conducted professional lab meetings at bars, invited students to late-night “hot tub parties” in their personal homes, and invited undergraduate students to use real cocaine during classes related to addiction as part of a “demonstration.”
Dartmouth Knew About Sexual Misconduct for More Than a Decade
Dartmouth knew about this conduct for years but failed to take action until Plaintiffs and other women in the PBS Department organized and filed a collective Title IX complaint against the professors. Student activism also brought media attention to the issue, prompting the New Hampshire Attorney General to launch a criminal probe into the professors’ conduct.
Presented with allegations of professors raping and abusing their students, Dartmouth nevertheless waited months before removing the professors from their labs, and made no effort in the interim to protect or warn its students. In fact, one of the seven Plaintiffs was raped by Whalen 20 days after her PBS colleagues filed their Title IX complaint.
Sanford Heisler Sharp Attorneys Comment
The Plaintiffs are represented by a Sanford Heisler Sharp team led by Chairman David Sanford, Baltimore Managing Partner Deborah K. Marcuse, Partner Steven Kelly, and Associate Nicole Wiitala. Charles G. Douglas of Douglas, Leonard & Garvey is local counsel for the Plaintiffs.
“What stands out even more than the appalling way tenured Ivy League professors acted is the incredible courage their victims have demonstrated. In more than 15 years of litigating sexual assault cases, I have never seen a group of survivors unite to seek justice and bring about change as these victims have done,” said Kelly.
“This lawsuit is the only means these women have to remedy the College’s past wrongs and ensure the institution implements meaningful reforms that will allow female students to engage in rigorous scientific studies in this discipline without being held back by gender discrimination and harassment,” said Marcuse.
“Dartmouth has not responded adequately or appropriately to the evidence and complaints of sexual harassment and the hostile environment in the Psychology and Brain Sciences department. It has failed in its responsibility to protect its female students,” said Wiitala.
“This class action lawsuit against Dartmouth puts the Trustees on notice of their responsibility to implement significant, systematic reforms before other female students are criminally impacted by Dartmouth’s callous indifference and perpetual inaction,” said Sanford.
Goals of the Lawsuit
Plaintiffs’ primary goal in bringing this suit is to shine a light on pervasive discrimination against women in academic sciences, at Dartmouth and beyond. Plaintiffs are committed to forcing Dartmouth to fully examine the root causes of the pervasive discrimination they suffered and to make whatever changes are necessary to ensure women scientists and female students in general are treated with the dignity and respect they deserve. One Plaintiff captured this concern, stating: “What keeps me up at night are thoughts of all the scientific discoveries that will not be made because so many women have been driven from science.”
- Click here to read the Preliminary Approval Order
- Click here to read the proposed class action settlement
- Click here to read the Joint Motion to Stay in Light of Settlement
- Click here to read the amended complaint
- Click here to read the original complaint
- August 6, 2019 - Dartmouth College and Nine Current and Former Dartmouth Students Announce Settlement of Title IX Class Action
- November 15, 2018 - Sanford Heisler Sharp Files $70 Million Sexual Assault and Gender Discrimination Class Action Against Dartmouth College
- Settlement in Dartmouth College Sexual Misconduct Gets Final Approval
- Federal Judge Likely To Give Final Approval In Dartmouth Settlement
- Sexual misconduct lawsuit settlement unique for class size
- Judge grants preliminary approval of $14 million lawsuit settlement
- Judge likely to OK settlement in Dartmouth sexual harassment case
- Dartmouth, Plaintiffs File Proposed Class Action Settlement
- Under proposed settlement, plaintiffs in Dartmouth College lawsuit will each receive at least $75,000
- Sexual misconduct settlement filed, Dartmouth denies wrongdoing
- Our Turn: Dartmouth talked the talk; now walk the walk
- Dartmouth settles sexual harassment lawsuit
- Dartmouth reaches $14 Million settlement in sexual harassment, assault lawsuit
- Dartmouth Reaches $14 Million Pact in Student Harassment Case
- Dartmouth Agrees To $14M Settlement Over ‘Predators Club’
- Dartmouth settles sexual harassment lawsuit for $14 million
- Dartmouth Reaches $14 Million Settlement in Sexual Abuse Lawsuit
1350 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019